Bishop Cline Challenges DPP on Appeal Decisions
Bishop John Cline criticizes the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) for appealing not guilty verdicts against public officials, arguing it financially burdens the Virgin Islands. He urges an end to what he sees as the UK's influence over local legal actions.
In a live Facebook broadcast on Wednesday, September 17, 2025, Bishop John Cline delivered a passionate critique of the Virgin Islands' legal system, particularly focusing on the actions of the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP). Drawing upon the findings of the Auditor General’s Report for 2024, Bishop Cline highlighted a series of cases involving public servants that, despite resulting in not guilty verdicts, are now subject to appeals by the DPP.
Among those mentioned were Dr Carolyn O'Neal-Morton, Najan Christopher, Wade N. Smith, Pascha Stoutt, and Roberto Harrigan, all of whom have been on paid leave for several years due to these ongoing legal proceedings. Bishop Cline expressed concern over the financial implications of these appeals, stating that the Virgin Islands is 'haemorrhaging money' as a result.
He pointed out that the funds used to maintain salaries for these individuals could instead contribute to the territory’s infrastructure and economic development. Furthermore, he accused the DPP of allowing the United Kingdom to exert undue influence over local affairs, urging a reevaluation of these legal actions for the sake of the community’s financial health and autonomy.
The criticism comes amid broader discussions about governance and financial management within the territory, highlighting a need for transparency and efficiency in public service operations. Bishop Cline’s call to withdraw the appeals and allow the affected public officers to return to work reflects a growing sentiment among residents for a more just and economically prudent legal system.
This situation underscores the ongoing challenges faced by the Virgin Islands in balancing legal integrity with fiscal responsibility, and the complex dynamics of its relationship with the UK. As the community awaits further developments, the debate over the DPP’s appeals and their impact on the territory's finances continues to unfold.
Primary source: VINO