Urgent Calls for Pause in BVI Constitutional
Claude Skelton Cline has reiterated his stance against the BVI proceeding with constitutional negotiations with the UK, citing a 'divided House' and the territory being 'under threat' as key reasons. His comments come amid a crucial period for the BVI, highlighting the complex dynamics at play as the territory debates its future constitutional relationship with the UK.
In a recent development concerning the British Virgin Islands' (BVI) constitutional future, Claude Skelton Cline, during his 'Honestly Speaking' radio show, has once again vocalized strong opposition to the territory proceeding with planned constitutional negotiations with the United Kingdom.
Skelton Cline's comments underscore a broader concern that the BVI is not in an equitable position to engage in such critical talks, especially given the current geopolitical climate and the internal pressures stemming from the aftermath of the Commission of Inquiry (COI) recommendations.
Skelton Cline pinpointed the tension and division within the House of Assembly, highlighting the impact of the COI's 148 recommendations, which have notably shifted powers away from ministers and have led to a 'divided House.' This division, according to Skelton Cline, hampers the territory's ability to effectively negotiate a new constitution.
Speaking on ZBVI 780 AM on September 9, 2025, Skelton Cline emphasized the danger of engaging in constitutional review and negotiation at this particular time due to geopolitical situations and the perceived threat from the UK, which undermines the territory's negotiating power. The backdrop to these discussions is the Commission of Inquiry report released in 2022, which suggested sweeping reforms and led to an Order in Council from the UK.
This order granted the UK powers to suspend parts of the BVI’s constitution if necessary reforms were not implemented, setting a precedent that has raised concerns about the territory's autonomy. In response, the BVI government agreed to a framework for reforms, with Premier Dr. Natalio Wheatley confirming plans to resume negotiations with the UK.
However, Skelton Cline argues that the political climate and the perceived threat from the UK are not conducive to fair or advantageous discussions. He has called on BVI residents, including UK citizens residing in the territory, to question the timing and wisdom of these negotiations.
As the BVI contemplates its next steps, the debates surrounding its constitutional future promise to remain a contentious and pivotal issue for the territory and its residents. Skelton Cline's recent comments have ignited a broader conversation within the BVI community about the future of the territory’s constitutional relationship with the UK, the balance of power, and how best to protect and advance the interests of the Virgin Islands in these complex negotiations.
Primary source: BVI News